Ten Minute Halacha - Ice Cubes and Whipped Cream on Shabbos

Speaker:
Ask speaker
Date:
June 15 2011
Length:
12min 18s
Downloads:
494
Views:
2429
Comments:
3

Series: Ten Minute Halacha

Venue: Yeshivat Lev Shlomo (Woodmere, NY) Yeshivat Lev Shlomo (Woodmere, NY)

Halacha:
Shabbat 

Collections: R' Lebowitz Ten Minute Halacha: Shabbos Prohibitions

    More from this:
    Comments
    3 comments     Leave a Comment
    Title:
    Comment:
    Anonymous: 
    1. Title: WHIPPED CREAM
      Author: Lawrence Adler
      Reply
      Rabbi Lebowitz, Listening to your 10 minute halacha on whipped cream I have questions about how you poskin. I’ll accept for argument’s sake all the strictest rulings regarding ice/water changes, but whipped cream from a can is not a phase change. Matter has 3 typical phases: solid, liquid and gas (excluding some atypical phase states like plasma). Whipped cream from a can is simply a gas injected into a liquid; the kitchen equivalent is beating egg whites to make a meringue. The gas is still gas and the cream (the ikar) is still a liquid albeit it with different viscosity and density. Since you are going from a liquid to a liquid there is no phase change and thus no nolad. Following your logic, opening a bottle of coke would not be allowed. Here the dissolved carbon dioxide which is not visible as a gas actually forms bubbles when the bottle is opened and the pressure is reduced. This too would seem to be nolad based on your reasoning; nowhere is opening a coke (for this reason) prohibited. I am not a food chemist or an expert in halacha so I would appreciate your thoughts. Larry Adler
    2. Title: whipped cream chemnistry
      Author: Lawrence Adler
      Reply
      Rabbi Lebowitz, Listening to your 10 minute halacha on whipped cream I have questions about how you poskin. I’ll accept for argument’s sake all the strictest rulings regarding ice/water changes, but whipped cream from a can is not a phase change. Matter has 3 typical phases: solid, liquid and gas (excluding some atypical phase states like plasma). Whipped cream from a can is simply a gas injected into a liquid; the kitchen equivalent is beating egg whites to make a meringue. The gas is still gas and the cream (the ikar) is still a liquid albeit it with different viscosity and density. Since you are going from a liquid to a liquid there is no phase change and thus no molad. Following your logic, opening a bottle of coke would not be allowed. Here the dissolved carbon dioxide which is not visible as a gas actually forms bubbles when the bottle is opened and the pressure is reduced. This too would seem to be molad based on your reasoning; nowhere is opening a coke (for this reason) prohibited. I am not a food chemist or an expert in halacha so I would appreciate your thoughts. Larry Adler
    3. Title: Thanks for Your Comment
      Author: Aryeh Lebowitz
      Reply

      While I do understand the science of the "change" in whipped cream, the halacha is not necessarily determined by the three categories of matter. It is likely determined by a percieved change. So, yes whipped cream is just a liquid with air, but it looks and feels like a solid. That may be enough to constitute a change in halacha. That is certainly the opinion of Rav Belsky (posek for the OU and somebody who certainly understands the science). The discussion in the poskim whether the change is sufficient to constitute nolad may depend on this very issue: is the halacha determined by perception or by scientific reality?

    Learning on the Marcos and Adina Katz YUTorah site is sponsored today by Debbie Nossbaum in loving memory of her father, Nathan Werdiger, נתן בן שלמה אלימלך and by Tommy and Perrie Gelb l'ilui nishmas Leah bas Yosef (Sternbach) Gelb on her yahrzeit on ה' טבת and by Harris and Elli Teitz Goldstein l'ilui nishmas Elli's beloved father, הרה'ג רב פינחס מרדכי טייץ, on his 30th yahrzeit on ד' טבת and in loving memory of Dr. Felix Glaubach, אפרים פישל בן ברוך, to mark his first yahrtzeit, by Miriam, his children, grandchildren & great grandchildren