- Rabbi Aryeh Lebowitz
- Date:
-
Series:
Daily Shiur
Venue: YU Wilf Campus
Gemara:Halacha: - Duration: 57 min
Please click here to donate and sponsor Torah learning on YUTorah
3 comments Leave a Comment
Author: False == 1 ? Anonymous : Yitz Rosenthal #44;
Hi. At the beginning of the shiur you mentioned Rav Soloveitchiks reason citing his father as to Tosfasos' reason as to why women, kohanim and leviim DO in fact say birkas hamazon - i.e. since the "mechayev" of birkas hamazon is being in the category of 'al shehinchalta laAvoseinu' - and women, kohanim and leviim do have a yerusha so to speak from the avos. If so, according to this, why do geirim have to say birkas hamazon??? Are geirim patur from birkas hamazon according to Tosafos???
Author: False == 1 ? Anonymous : Yitz Rosenthal #44;
Hi. At the beginning of the shiur you mentioned Rav Soloveitchiks reason citing his father as to Tosfasos' reason as to why women, kohanim and leviim DO in fact say birkas hamazon - i.e. since the "mechayev" of birkas hamazon is being in the category of 'al shehinchalta laAvoseinu' - and women, kohanim and leviim do have a yerusha so to speak from the avos. If so, according to this, why do geirim have to say birkas hamazon??? Are geirim patur from birkas hamazon according to Tosafos???
Author: False == 1 ? Anonymous : Yitz Rosenthal #44;
Hi. At the beginning of the shiur you mentioned Rav Soloveitchiks reason citing his father as to Tosfasos' reason as to why women, kohanim and leviim DO in fact say birkas hamazon - i.e. since the "mechayev" of birkas hamazon is being in the category of 'al shehinchalta laAvoseinu' - and women, kohanim and leviim do have a yerusha so to speak from the avos. If so, according to this, why do geirim have to say birkas hamazon??? Are geirim patur from birkas hamazon according to Tosafos???