Hi. At the beginning of the shiur you mentioned Rav Soloveitchiks reason citing his father as to Tosfasos' reason as to why women, kohanim and leviim DO in fact say birkas hamazon - i.e. since the "mechayev" of birkas hamazon is being in the category of 'al shehinchalta laAvoseinu' - and women, kohanim and leviim do have a yerusha so to speak from the avos.
If so, according to this, why do geirim have to say birkas hamazon??? Are geirim patur from birkas hamazon according to Tosafos???
Hi. At the beginning of the shiur you mentioned Rav Soloveitchiks reason citing his father as to Tosfasos' reason as to why women, kohanim and leviim DO in fact say birkas hamazon - i.e. since the "mechayev" of birkas hamazon is being in the category of 'al shehinchalta laAvoseinu' - and women, kohanim and leviim do have a yerusha so to speak from the avos.
If so, according to this, why do geirim have to say birkas hamazon??? Are geirim patur from birkas hamazon according to Tosafos???
Hi. At the beginning of the shiur you mentioned Rav Soloveitchiks reason citing his father as to Tosfasos' reason as to why women, kohanim and leviim DO in fact say birkas hamazon - i.e. since the "mechayev" of birkas hamazon is being in the category of 'al shehinchalta laAvoseinu' - and women, kohanim and leviim do have a yerusha so to speak from the avos.
If so, according to this, why do geirim have to say birkas hamazon??? Are geirim patur from birkas hamazon according to Tosafos???
Learning on the Marcos and Adina Katz YUTorah site is sponsored today
by Sigal Gottlieb and Lenny Moisein honor ofthe wedding of Temima Tova and Yedidya Moise and by Henry Silberman to mark the yahrtzeit of Julia Silberman, Yura Sheva bas Chaim Yosef Silberman and by Reuben Pludwinski in memory of his mother Itta bas Yehudah Leib a"h
3 comments Leave a Comment
Author: Yitz Rosenthal
Hi. At the beginning of the shiur you mentioned Rav Soloveitchiks reason citing his father as to Tosfasos' reason as to why women, kohanim and leviim DO in fact say birkas hamazon - i.e. since the "mechayev" of birkas hamazon is being in the category of 'al shehinchalta laAvoseinu' - and women, kohanim and leviim do have a yerusha so to speak from the avos. If so, according to this, why do geirim have to say birkas hamazon??? Are geirim patur from birkas hamazon according to Tosafos???
Author: Yitz Rosenthal
Hi. At the beginning of the shiur you mentioned Rav Soloveitchiks reason citing his father as to Tosfasos' reason as to why women, kohanim and leviim DO in fact say birkas hamazon - i.e. since the "mechayev" of birkas hamazon is being in the category of 'al shehinchalta laAvoseinu' - and women, kohanim and leviim do have a yerusha so to speak from the avos. If so, according to this, why do geirim have to say birkas hamazon??? Are geirim patur from birkas hamazon according to Tosafos???
Author: Yitz Rosenthal
Hi. At the beginning of the shiur you mentioned Rav Soloveitchiks reason citing his father as to Tosfasos' reason as to why women, kohanim and leviim DO in fact say birkas hamazon - i.e. since the "mechayev" of birkas hamazon is being in the category of 'al shehinchalta laAvoseinu' - and women, kohanim and leviim do have a yerusha so to speak from the avos. If so, according to this, why do geirim have to say birkas hamazon??? Are geirim patur from birkas hamazon according to Tosafos???