Masechet Shabbat 45a: Do we accept the view of Rebby Shimon regarding Muktza in the case of Chittim Shezaran BiKarka?

Speaker:
Ask speaker
Date:
November 20 2013
Length:
55min 11s
Downloads:
6
Views:
84
Comments:
0

Series: Daily Shiur

Venue: Jerusalem Jerusalem

Gemara:
Shabbat 
Halacha:
Orach Chaim,  Rabbinic Laws,  Shabbat 

Collections: Rabbi Berzon: Shabbat

Description

The debate amongst poskim re: Chittim Shezaran BiKarka should depend upon the reality. If there was Hashrasha clearly even R' Shimon would prohibit the chittim under the category of Muktza Maachmas Issur Meleches Ketzira. All Rishonim agree that there was no Hashrash. On the other hand since the chittim are covered by soil there is Melechet Chofer. The issue is more than technical. Muktza Maachmas Issur requires an Issur Shabbos. There are Melachos DeRabanan & gezeiros DeRabanan; the latter do not belong to Shabbos per se.

    More from this:
    Comments
    0 comments     Leave a Comment
    Title:
    Comment:
    Anonymous: 

    Learning on the Marcos and Adina Katz YUTorah site is sponsored today by the Spira Family l'ilui nishmat Chanoch ben Moshe Chaim, in memory of Dr. Thomas Spira and by Dr. Michael and Yael Buckstein l'ilui nishmas Raizel Shayna bas Meir Mendel and Yisrael Zvi ben Zev