Gemara:

Shabbat 

Collections: Rabbi Rosensweig Itamar Columbia Shabbat

Description

Columbia shiur: different interpretations of the gemara's distinction between yad and guf; Rashi's interpretation of yado lo nach al gabei karka, Tosfos's understanding of Rashi, Rosh's scenario; Tosfos's interpretations of yado basar gufo garir and whether that is a concern of hanacha of chiluf reshut- Meiri and Rabbenu Chananel; Nafka Mina between Rashi and Tosafot- Ritva; a relative definition of hanacha- tosafot and tosafot yeshanim; hanacha lechiyuv and hanacha leinyan akirah le'acharehah- Ritva and Tosafot; the relevance of the sugya on 92a for 3a- tosafot 3a, tosafot 92a, Rashba 3a, Ritva 92a.