Please click here to donate and sponsor Torah learning on YUTorah
- Downloads:
- 0
- Views:
- 1169
- Comments:
- 0
Some later commentaries have understood the Ramban’s intent to be that not only does a notion of “chatzi shiur” exist on a quantitative level, prohibiting actions involving objects that fall short of minimum measurements, but also on a qualitative level, prohibiting actions that approach transgressions while not actually crossing that line. (See Resp. L’Horot Natan, I, 57, noting the Rambam’s words in Hil. Ma’akhalot Asurot, 3:6; note also Resp. Eretz Tzvi, I, 1, fn. on page 56).
It is possible, though, to understand the Ramban’s intent differently. It may be that he was not suggesting that contact with an ervah is a “chatzi shiur” of the prohibition of intimacy, and thus prohibited, but rather that chatzi shiur provides a model for the category: biblically prohibited, related to a punishable offense, but yet lacking a punishment itself.
Assuming the prohibition is biblical, it would seem to fall into a category of prohibitions that are rooted in the Torah, but are in intent similar to rabbinic prohibitions, as they are protective in nature. R. Yosef Engel (Lekach Tov, 8), in an essay on the topic, lists 17 such examples. This particular prohibition is especially relevant as it is identified by the Avot D’Rav Natan (ch. 1) as an example of such a notion (in interpretation of the mishnah , Avot 1:1 : “create a safeguard for the Torah”).
Gemara:
Collections: Rabbi Feldman Mini Shiur (Daf)
References: Shabbat: 13a
Publication:
Mini Shiur (Daf) Volume 1
-
Understanding Pirsumei Nisa- Rabbi Daniel Z. Feldman
- Date:
-
Machshava:
- Duration: 28 min
-
What is Chanukah?- Rabbi Daniel Z. Feldman
- Date:
-
Halacha:
-
Melachos of Shabbos and Psik Reisha Part 1- Rabbi Daniel Z. Feldman
- Date:
-
Gemara:Machshava:
- Duration: 42 min
-
Lashon Hara and Educational Issues- Rabbi Daniel Z. Feldman
- Date:
-
Halacha:
- Duration: 31 min
-
Why don't we mention Chanukah in על המחיה?- Rabbi Yehoshua Grunstein
- Date:
-
Gemara:
- Duration: 8 min
-
How much money do you need to spend on Chanukah candles?
- Rabbi Yehoshua Grunstein
- Date:
-
Halacha:Machshava:Mishna:
- Duration: 9 min
-
Kavsa Zakuk La On Erev Shabbos #2
- Rabbi Ally Ehrman
- Date:
-
Gemara:Halacha:
- Duration: 27 min
-
Kavsa Zakuk La On Erev Shabbos
- Rabbi Ally Ehrman
- Date:
-
Gemara:Machshava:
- Duration: 19 min
-
Why are there THREE different ways to Light a Menorah?
- Rabbi Yehoshua Grunstein
- Date:
-
Gemara:Halacha:Machshava:
- Duration: 6 min
-
Shabbos 5786 - 28 - Lisha 3; Intro to Bishul- Rabbi Michoel Zylberman
- Date:
-
Venue:
YU Wilf Campus
Gemara:Halacha: - Duration: 1 hr 15 min
0 comments Leave a Comment