Mini-Chabura, daf 76: Limitations on Liability for Murder

Speaker:
Ask speaker
Date:
April 29 2010
Length:
12min 25s
Downloads:
5
Views:
709
Comments:
1

Gemara:
Sanhedrin 

Collections: Rabbi Meth Mini Chabura

References: Sanhedrin: 76a ,  Sanhedrin: 76b ,  Sanhedrin: 77a ,  Sanhedrin: 77b ,  Sanhedrin: 78a  

Description

I. Three salient characteristics of tying a person in the sun: 1) he will surely die; 2) the sun is present while he is being tied; 3) the process of heatstroke has already begun. When the third is absent, is the murderer still liable? Also, what defines the "beginning" of a process? II. Can an inevitable consequence of my actions still be considered a grama?

    More from this:
    Comments
    1 comment     Leave a Comment
    Title:
    Comment:
    Anonymous: 
    1. Title: Correction
      Author: False == 1 ? Anonymous : Ephraim Meth &##44;
      Reply

      <p>I asked a doctor about how heatstroke works, and he explained that the body is constantly generating heat, and constantly dispelling heat. Hence, the process of death from heatstroke cannot simply begin when the temperature rises above 98.6. Rather, heatstroke begins when the body exhibits dangerously abnormal symptoms. Similarly, the process of starvation does not begin as soon as one stops eating. It begins when the body begins to exhibit abnormal symptoms, such as breaking down muscle tissue for energy.</p> <p>ETM</p>

    Learning on the Marcos and Adina Katz YUTorah site is sponsored today by Larry Adler & Joan Presby in honor of Rabbi Yitzchak Etshalom's YUTorah shiurim and by Benjy Owen in memory of Sam Owen, Shemuel Reuven ben Yehudit Rachel and by Fran & Jerry Weinberg l'ilui nishmot Yaakov Yosef ben Moshe Ahron and Sheindel Perel bat Moshe