Masechet Bava Matzia 28a: Two claimants on the same lost object & establishing a hierarchy of evidence from average סימנים to מובהקים all the way up to עדים

Speaker:
Ask speaker
Date:
October 24 2016
Length:
1h 26min 41s
Downloads:
14
Views:
1188
Comments:
0

Series: Daf Yomi

Venue: Jerusalem Jerusalem

Gemara:

Collections: R' Berzon Daf Yomi Bava Metzia

References: Bava Metzia: 28a  

Description

The sugya of Rava in Bava Matzia 28a addresses the issue of 2 claimants on the same lost object & how do we establish a hierarchy of evidence beginning with average סימנים climbing the more reliable and powerful evidence of Simanim מובהקים all the way up to the greatest proof, i.e. עדים. What if the two claimants present the same level evidence? Can we split the lost object into 2? Or must we require that the finder continue to hold on to the find until 1 of the claimants can establish absolute proof? Are Simanim מובהקים as great as witnesses? What is the status of a single witness? What do the witnesses tell us? We will discuss the relative 'weight' of the following Simanim: length, breadth, weight, a hole in the Get. The Mishna of הכרזה.

    More from this:
    Comments
    0 comments
    Leave a Comment
    Title:
    Comment:
    Anonymous: 

    Learning on the Marcos and Adina Katz YUTorah site is sponsored today by Ron Zanger l'ilui nishmos יהושע בן אהרון ומרים בת חיים ז״ל לברכה and by Sara and Eric Pollak l'zecher nishmas Moshe ben Yehuda and Shifra bas Menachem Mendel